the infamous GRY puzzle
| The GRY collection at www.MAZES.com: |
-
Our webmaster's thorough explanation
-
One Hundred Words that end in -gry:
-
Another GRY expert and his explanation
-
A third expert's GRY point of view
|
|
The original "GRY Puzzle" went something like this:
Solvable: Think of words that end
in g-r-y. Angry and hungry are two of them. There are only three words in
the English language. What is the third word? The word is a common word,
one that people use everyday, and if you were listening carefully, I have
already told you what it is. What is the third word?
Unfortunately, most versions of the "gry puzzle" have been ruined by well-meaning
people who add words that they believe should be there. BUT ... these badly
updated puzzles have no answer because of the way they are worded. To give
you an idea, here is one of the unsolvable versions of the GRY puzzle:
Unsolvable: There are only three words
in the English language that end in GRY. Two are HUNGRY and ANGRY. The third
is one that you use every day. If you've listened carefully, you already
know what the word is. What is the third word?
Another of the bastardized versions goes like this:
Unsolvable: Think of words that end in
g-r-y. Angry and hungry are two of them. There are only three words in the
English language that end in g-r-y. What is the third word? The word is a
common word, one that people use everyday, and if you were listening carefully,
I have already told you what it is. What is the third word?
These ruined versions are wrongly worded. The people who re-worded the puzzle
probably tried to do it by memory, and accidentally misquoted the original
puzzle, ending up with statements that are completely false.
These statements are false in the wrongly worded puzzles:
** There are only three words in the English language that end in GRY.
FALSE!!! There are more than three words that end in -gry:
aggry, gry, anhungry, puggry, conyngry, iggry, meagry, nangry, podagry, and
many others
(100 "gry" words with meanings are on page 2 of our
collection)
** The word is a common word, one that people use everyday
Again, FALSE! None of these additional -gry words are common. None
of them are words you use everyday. EVERY "gry" word except hungry and angry
are either archaic, outmoded, or part of the language that is practically
never used. At least, I don't use any of them very often.
Let's look at the GRY puzzle again!!!
Let's look at the original puzzle again, and remember that it was written
to be a verbal puzzle. (This puzzle was not written by an English
teacher.) This time, as you read the puzzle, I want you to keep in mind
that you already know everything that you need to know in order to solve
this puzzle. Also, try to ignore anything you think might be there to distract
you from finding the answer.
Solvable: Think of words that end
in g-r-y. Angry and hungry are two of them. There are only three words in
the English language. What is the third word? The word is a common word,
one that people use everyday, and if you were listening carefully, I have
already told you what it is. What is the third word?
A good riddle usually has a trick to it, the kind of trick that gives you
that Ah Ha! satisfaction when you figure out the trick. This
puzzle actually has two tricks involved. Can you figure out one or
more of the tricks that the author used to mislead you? Think about
it as you read the next paragraph. In my opinion, the original
author created the gry puzzle as a hoax. The riddle is deliberately
tricky. To solve the riddle, you have to figure out what the tricks are.
First Trick - Grammar
The original author must have created the GRY puzzle to be a verbal
riddle, because it is not written with correct punctuation. If your English
teacher were to write this puzzle, he or she would have added at least two
pieces of punctuation. But, if so, it would not be a puzzle, because there
would be no trick to it, the answer would be obvious. One trick, then, is
in the punctuation. When you figure out the punctuation, you will have figured
out one of the two tricks, and you might just know the answer, but don't
try to figure it out now. I tell you about it first, because it
might help you to see how the other trick affects the puzzle.
Second Trick - Misdirection
The author used misdirection to mislead us. He included information
that has no relevance to the puzzle. Do you remember math puzzles where the
question included a lot of extraneous information? When you got to the question,
you then had to figure out what information pertained to the question and
you were supposed to ignore the rest.
An example of misdirection in a math puzzle
Let me give you an example of misdirection. Read this next paragraph to yourself
(but you are only allowed to read it once, because this is also a verbal
puzzle, one that you would normally ask a friend).
You are a bus driver. At the first bus stop, three people get on. At the
second bus stop, one person gets off and five people get on. At the next
stop, seven people get on. At the next stop, two people get off and nobody
gets on. At the next-to-the-last stop, nobody gets off and three people get
on. At the last stop, everybody gets off.
Are you ready for the question? If you are reading this to yourself,
quickly cover the paragraph above, then read and try to answer the question
below without peeking at what you just read?
Here's the question:
How old is the bus driver?
Or, you could ask yourself
What is the bus driver's name?
I bet you were expecting me to ask a math question, like how
many people rode the bus?
In order to solve this transportation puzzle, you need to IGNORE all the
extraneous data and only pay attention to the pieces of information
that pertain to the question. Read the puzzle again, but this time, read
only the first sentence and the final question.
You are a bus driver.
(extraneous data snipped)
How old is the bus driver?
Now, the puzzle is solvable. Sorry, though, I can't tell you the answer,
because I don't know how old you are, or what your name is. (By the way,
there are a few other tricks that you can play with this puzzle. If you think
the person you're reading this puzzle to knows the regular question, you
could ask him "How many stops did the bus make?"
Back to the GRY puzzle again
So, you need to reread the original "gry puzzle" and this time, figure out
what you need to read, and what you should ignore, in order to get an answer.
Here's what I want you to do:
-
Read the puzzle again
Think of words that end in g-r-y. Angry and hungry are two of them. There
are only three words in the English language. What is the third word? The
word is a common word, one that people use everyday, and if you were listening
carefully, I have already told you what it is. What is the third word?
-
At least one sentence has nothing to do with the riddle. Ignore those sentences.
-
Read the puzzle again, but this time, only read the important stuff.
-
Do all this before you scroll down.
Okay, now that you have done that, let me read the puzzle to you again,
but this time, let me phrase it a slightly different way, and see if that
helps you see what information is the "red herring" in this puzzle (a red
herring is like the "wild goose" in the expression "a wild goose chase."
The red herring is the information that sends your mind off in the wrong
direction.
Think of people who were born in Portland, Indiana. John Knoderer and
David Knoderer are two of them. There are only three words in the English
language. What is the third word? The word is a common word, one that people
use everyday, and if you were listening carefully, I have already told you
what it is. What is the third word?
Now, do you see what the "red herring" is?
Looking back at the original puzzle, we could ask ourselves what is wrong
with the punctuation. Your English teacher would never write the puzzle this
way. He or she would have added quotes in one position to make sure that
we understood what was being said.
Of course, as I intimated above, our main task is to figure out what sentences
have nothing to do with the rest of the puzzle. All that stuff about "GRY"
is supposed to make you come up with the wrong answer.
Now, you know the two tricks that you need to pay attention to in order to
solve this puzzle. First, ignore the "red herring," and second, figure out
what the puzzle really says (add the missing punctuation). Let me help you
ignore the "red herring" by crossing out the extraneous information:
Think of words that end in g-r-y. Angry and hungry are two of
them. There are only three words in the English language. What
is the third word? The word is a common word, one that people use everyday,
and if you were listening carefully, I have already told you what it is.
What is the third word?
Second, we need to add the missing punctuation, and we probably should capitalize
one word that wasn't capitalized:
Think of words that end in g-r-y. Angry and hungry are two of
them. There are only three words in "The English language". What
is the third word? The word is a common word, one that people use everyday,
and if you were listening carefully, I have already told you what it is.
What is the third word?
Are there only three words in the
English Language that end in g-r-y?
This is the other problem with the puzzle the way that many people write
it. When one of the unsolvable versions of the puzzle says, "There
are only three words in the English language that end in g-r-y" and "(the
third word) is one that you use every day," they are not just using
misdirection, they are actually stating falsehoods.
-
There are only three words in the English language that end in
g-r-y.
False: there are many other words that end in g-r-y, but very few
people can think of any of them easily.
-
It is one that you use every day ...
False: Except for angry and hungry, all the other words are very uncommon,
and only someone in a particular industry might use one or another of them
everyday. (For example, someone in the bead industry might use aggry
almost every day.)
Look back at the first version of the puzzle and you'll see that every statement
is true.
-
Think of words that end in g-r-y. Angry and hungry are two of them.
very true, angry and hungry are two of the words that end in g-r-y.
-
There are only three words in the English language.
also true, especially if you remember that this statement, properly punctuated
and capitalized, would read: There are only three words in "The English
Language."
-
What is the third word? The word is a common word, ...
true, it is a common word
-
one that people use everyday, ...
yep, we use that word everyday (actually, we use what that word stands for,
I'm using it right now)
-
and if you were listening carefully, I have already told you what it is.
...
yes, I said the word as part of the puzzle.
-
What is the third word?
Where did this puzzle come from?
Different people have different opinions, and say that different versions
are the original. But nobody can find one of the original graying sheets
of paper that were copied and passed out at college campuses years ago. One
official source, Lederer, thinks it originated in 1975, but I know that it
existed before that time because I remember hearing and seeing the puzzle
when I was in college. Since I graduated in 1974, I know it was before 1974.
Who knows? I might have met the author, since I remember it before it became
famous, and I did go to Indiana University at the same time as the only IU
student ever to get a Bachelor's Degree in Puzzles (and that person is now
Puzzles Editor at the New York Times).
Some people think that the original puzzle started out with the sentence,
"Think of words that end in g or y." When you say that fast enough,
it sounds like "G R Y." But then, we end up with lots of words that end in
"g" or "y", so the statement that there are "only three words" is still false.
Rang, sing, any, or say are all words that end in g or y. With this
version of the puzzle, the right answer depends on who you talk to. I even
heard one person insist that "say" was the answer to the puzzle because it
ends in y and he used the word "say" several times when he told the puzzle.
In my opinion, the "G or Y" version was created by someone who heard an
impossible version of the puzzle and he manipulated the puzzle into something
that he could justify an answer with, even if two different people would
come up with two different answers.
The beauty of the original puzzle
Let's look at the original puzzle again:
Think of words that end in g-r-y. Angry and hungry are two of them. There
are only three words in the English language. What is the third word? The
word is a common word, one that people use everyday, and if you were listening
carefully, I have already told you what it is. What is the third word?
The beauty of this "original" is that there is only one logical answer, once
you get around the trickery. Of course, it helps to see the proper punctuation,
which is not in the printed version of the puzzle because it would
give it away.
Think of words that end in g-r-y. Angry and hungry are two of them. There
are only three words in "The English Language." What is the third word?
The word is a common word, one that people use everyday, and if you were
listening carefully, I have already told you what it is. What is the third
word?
See what proper punctuation did to the third sentence? (I never know if I
should capitalize Language when I correct the grammar. If it's a title,
it should be capitalized.) We have a true statement, no matter how you
read it. Look at the phrase "The English language" and tell me how many words
are in that phrase or title? Yes, three. There are only three words
in "The English Language".
And, as you can see, the first two sentences have nothing to do with the
puzzle, other than to confuse you and to make thousands of people search
their dictionaries for words that end in -gry. The puzzle really starts with
the third sentence, and could have ended after the fourth sentence.
This puzzle could just as easily been written:
There are only three words in "the English language." What is the third
word?
Do you know the answer now?
The answer, of course, is "Language". The first two words were "The" and
"English".
To review:
-
There are only three words in the English Language that end in -gry
FALSE: there are more than three words that end in -gry
-
The third word that ends in -gry is a common word
FALSE: angry and hungry are the only common words that end in -gry
A few of the uncommon -gry words are listed here. There are 100 further below.
-
Aggry beads are colored, variegated, glass beads of ancient manufacture,
much used on the Gold Coast of Africa; unknown origin; usually used
attributively.
-
Shakespeare used anhungry in one of his plays as a synonym for hungry.
-
A puggry, variant form of puggree, is a Hindu scarf or light turban
or head-covering wrapped around a helmet or hat which trails down the back
to keep the hot sun off of your neck, worn by inhabitants of the Indian
subcontinent.
-
A gry is a medieval unit of measurement equaling one-tenth of a line.
-
Conyngry, an obsolete dialectal variant of conyger, means "rabbit
warren"
-
iggry or ijri means "Hurry up!" - Egyptian colloquial Arabic
pronunciation, brought back after the First World War by members of British
and Australian forces who had fought in Egypt.
-
meagry, having a meagre appearance. Obsolete.
-
nangry, A variant form of angry. Obsolete.
-
podagry, Dodder, or the condition of a plant infested with it.
-
Other -gry words are variant spellings, augry is variant for augury, begry
for beggary, bewgry for buggery, braggry for braggery
I have found lots of other sites with information. The rest of this letter
has some additional information, including 100 -gry words, which has some
overlap with the above.
John
(webmaster (at) mazes.com)
www.MAZES.com
P.S. People who enjoy turning phone numbers into words might be interested
in knowing that our area code spells GRY, certainly an appropriate area code
for the webmaster of www.MAZES.com, a puzzle page. Unfortunately, I couldn't
get MAZEMAN as a phone number (because our phones don't have Z's on them),
but I did get BYTEMAN. So, I guess that I can call myself "1-GRY-BYTEMAN".
| The GRY collection at www.MAZES.com: |
-
Our webmaster's thorough explanation
-
One Hundred Words that end in -gry:
-
Another GRY expert and his explanation
-
A third expert's GRY point of view
|
|
Copyright 1998/2004 by Rev. John Amazing,
D.Div.
(webmaster (at)
mazes.com)
This page was originally created in 1998, and updated in 1999 &
2004.
The master copy is archived at
<
http://www.MAZES.com/ChickenOrEgg.html>.
If you enjoy what you learn from any of my articles, I invite you to visit
my web pages:
If you really appreciate the effort that went into the development
of John's many pages,
we encourage you to send appropriate donations to the author:
The "Amazing" Rev. John

www.GodLovesEveryone.org
P O Box 235
Sulphur Springs, ARkansas 72768-0235
USA
Telephone number: 1-GRY-BYTEMAN (1-479-298-3626)
(GRY =
a famous puzzle)
***** end of article *****
|